Savigny Luxury Index

Market Pulse / Valuation Jitters Prompt Luxury Sell-Off

The Italian government’s bailout of several major banks proved the proverbial final straw and prompted a late sell-off in luxury stocksThe Savigny Luxury Index (“SLI”) fell almost 3 percent this month, relative to a decline of 1 percent for the MSCI. There had been some lingering concerns about high valuations throughout the month, resulting in downward pressure on our index, but the final straw came with the Italian government’s bail-out of two regional banks at the end of June.

Big news

A mix of improvement and uncertainty: that’s the picture for the luxury sector. Whilst leading brands continue to outperform (see below), nobody is taking it easy. Valuations are seen as very high. The Chinese market recovery, currently priced in luxury stocks and so welcome by the sector after the brutal slowdown caused by President Xi Jinping’s anti-corruption drive, may come under threat at the next National Congress of the Communist Party (expected in November this year): should the government become concerned about currently rising debt levels and capital flight from the country, it could introduce measures to tighten liquidity and thus dampen luxury demand. In the US, early hopes for a swift implementation of the key economic measures of the Trump administration have been lost in what looks increasingly like a political pantomime. Even undisputed sector king Bernard Arnault is publicly weary of a forthcoming global crisis. In this context no wonder that the Italian government’s bail-out of two Venetian banks at a cost of up to eur17 billion revived prospects of a Eurozone debt crisis and triggered some short selling in the markets.

Nevertheless, the best companies are bullish on fundamentals, in contrast with the poor state of traditional US retail in general and department stores in particular. LVMH is firing on all cylinders. Kering’s Saint Laurent hosted an investor day, during which the company announced it expected revenues to double in the next three to five years, on the back of six consecutive years of 20+ percent growth per annum. Mulberry also came out with positive results and outlook, posting a 21 percent rise in profit backed by successful product launches and growing online sales.

Corporate activity was brisk in June. In hard luxury, Chinese investment fund Fortune Fountain Capital acquired French crystal group Baccarat for eur185 million; Theo Fennell was bought out of administration in an MBO backed by UK private equity firm Endless LLP; and Luxemburg-based investment company Helarb Group acquired Swiss watch parts manufacturer Le Temps Manufacture. In fashion and apparel, children’s clothes brand Simonetta was acquired by Italian clothing and textile company ISA; fashion group BCBG Max Azria was acquired by Li & Fung subsidiary Global Brands Group for a cash consideration of $23 million – the group, which filed for insolvency this year, had been acquired by Guggenheim Partners in 2015 for $135 million; and the Pinault family investment vehicle Artemis acquired a minority stake in Maison Valli, with a view to acquiring control at a later stage. Finally, Unilever acquired prestige cosmetics brand Hourglass; and Qatar Luxury Group quietly disposed of a controlling stake in its French leather goods subsidiary Le Tanneur to Tolomei Participations, a local turnaround specialist.

Going up

  • US affordable luxury stocks staged a rebound this month, led by Michael Kors and Ralph Lauren, each posting gains of 9 percent. The segment had been under severe downward pressure, causing operators to reduce discounting and retrench activities.
  • Mulberry’s share price gained almost 3 percent on the month on the back of impressive results, spurred on by the successful return of the brand to its affordable luxury roots 

Going down

  • Italian stocks took a dip at the end of the month following the government’s controversial bail-out of two Veneto banks.
  • Burberry fell nearly 9 percent amidst controversy over executive pay, advisory group Institutional Shareholder Services describing the criteria for an exceptional multi-million pound share award to Christopher Bailey as “murky” and criticising payments to other executives.

What to watch

The world has gone topsy-turvy, with geopolitical as well as economic indicators going in multiple directions at once. Who would have thought that a Chinese President would, at Davos, assume the mantle of global trade and the fight against climate change in the face of an inward-looking, protectionist US President, or bet on a complete reversal of prospects between the UK and France, the former increasingly fragilised by self-inflicted woes and the latter morphing from relative decline to the rejuvenated hopeful? Now more than ever the fundamentals of the luxury sector are all the more important: quality, desirability and differentiation, healthy margins and the ability to directly engage and properly service the customer in multiple channels. It is not rocket science, but there are no shortcuts.

Sector valuation